Sign-up to our newsletter and we'll also send you our free ebook on Navigating Social Situations.
Imagine confidently joining any dinner party, indulging in holiday feasts guilt-free, and making lasting memories, all while edging closer to your goals. Sign up now!
Over the past decade, collagen has gone from a beauty buzzword to a mainstream wellness staple. It’s found in everything from pills and powders to protein bars and coffee creamers–marketed as a catch-all solution for wrinkles, joint pain, injuries, and recovery. In some circles, it’s even touted as a viable protein alternative for building muscle.
But does collagen actually deliver on these promises? And more importantly, should it have a place in your diet if your primary goals are performance, body composition, or long-term health?
In this article, we’ll break down the science behind collagen—what it is, what it does, and whether it’s worth the hype or just another overblown supplement trend.
Collagen is the most abundant structural protein in the human body, comprising roughly one-third of total protein mass. It plays a vital role in holding your body together—quite literally—by providing structure and strength to your skin, bones, cartilage, tendons, and ligaments. If it bends, stretches, or cushions impact, collagen likely has something to do with it.
There are 28 different types of collagen identified so far, but types I through IV make up the majority. And type I alone accounts for over 90% of collagen in your body.
What sets collagen apart from other proteins is its distinct amino acid profile. It’s rich in glycine, proline, and hydroxyproline, which support the tightly coiled triple-helix structure that keeps collagen strong under stress. However, since it’s low in essential amino acids, collagen is considered an incomplete protein.
Most of the collagen research examines hydrolyzed collagen, also known as collagen peptides. This form is pre-digested into smaller chains of amino acids and peptides to improve absorption. That said, a handful of studies use undenatured type II collagen (UC-II), a less processed form that retains its original structure.
You might be wondering: Don’t we just break all protein down into amino acids during digestion anyway? In most cases, yes–but not always. Some studies have found collagen-derived peptides in the bloodstream after consuming hydrolyzed collagen. These peptides may stimulate cells called fibroblasts to produce collagen and repair tissues. Similarly, a portion of undenatured type II collagen may survive digestion long enough to modulate the immune system in the gut and reduce inflammatory signaling.
Then there’s also interest in glycine, the most common amino acid in collagen. Glycine has anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties, which could help explain some observed benefits of collagen.
In short, collagen is complex. It’s not a single protein, but a family of proteins with diverse functions and supplemental forms. And while some mechanisms look promising, the full picture of how (or if) collagen supplements improve health is still unfolding.
Collagen is sometimes sold as a multi-purpose supplement–and, in some cases, the research backs that up. While it’s far from a miracle fix or fountain of youth, collagen may offer measurable benefits for skin health, joint function, and injury recovery, particularly in certain populations.
True to its roots in the beauty industry, collagen’s most well-documented effects are in the realm of skin aging. Studies consistently show that daily supplementation with hydrolyzed collagen can improve skin elasticity and hydration, while also reducing the appearance of age-related wrinkles. That said, most of this research has been conducted in older populations already experiencing age-related collagen loss, so whether the same effects apply to younger individuals remains unclear.
Collagen may support joint comfort and mobility, especially in individuals with arthritis or chronic joint discomfort. Improvements in pain, perceived stiffness, and joint function have been reported for both hydrolyzed collagen and undenatured type II collagen. However, some studies have failed to find increases in connective tissue synthesis, raising questions about the mechanisms behind these benefits. And because much of the research showing positive outcomes is funded by collagen manufacturers, results should be interpreted with caution.
There’s also evidence that collagen may aid in recovery from exercise-related injuries like Achilles tendinopathy or knee discomfort. A 2021 systematic review reported reductions in joint pain alongside better joint functionality and range of motion when individuals combined collagen supplementation with exercise, recommending 5-15 grams of collagen peptides at least an hour before exercise for maximal benefits. These studies suggest that collagen supplementation may be most beneficial when paired with targeted loading protocols, which help stimulate tissue remodeling. Whether collagen alone can provide similar effects without structured rehab is still uncertain.
While collagen shows potential in some health domains, its role in muscle building is much clearer and less flattering. Collagen is a poor stimulator of muscle growth due to its low levels of essential amino acids–especially leucine, which plays a key role in activating muscle protein synthesis.
Several studies have confirmed that collagen supplementation does not meaningfully increase muscle protein synthesis, even after resistance training, when compared to complete proteins. And while collagen combined with leucine is better at supporting muscle growth, it’s still no match for whey.
The bottom line: If your goal is to maximize lean mass, collagen isn’t the right tool for the job.
Whether collagen supplementation makes sense for you ultimately depends on your goals. If you’re aiming to support skin health, manage joint discomfort, or aid injury recovery, collagen could be a reasonable option. But if your focus is improving body composition or building muscle, there are far better levers to pull.
It’s also important to consider the calorie trade-off. While undenatured type II collagen is typically used in small, 40 mg doses and adds virtually no calories, hydrolyzed collagen peptides are consumed in gram-level quantities that do contribute to your daily calorie intake. If you're in a deficit, it might be hard to fit in collagen without displacing more nutrient-dense or filling foods. And while you should count collagen toward your total calories, it should not count toward your daily protein target.
So is collagen worth it?
If you’re chasing muscle growth, collagen won’t get you there. But if you’re a middle-aged adult aiming to support skin health or manage joint discomfort, it might offer modest benefits.
As with any supplement, context matters. Collagen isn’t a magic fix, but depending on your goals, it could be a helpful addition to your routine. Just don’t expect it to replace high-quality dietary protein, a solid training program, or a well-rounded lifestyle.
More research is still needed to fully understand how collagen works, who benefits most, and how best to use it. For now, collagen may have a place for some—but it shouldn’t be your first-line strategy.
Looking for real results? With Carbon Diet Coach, you can personalize your nutrition, hit your protein targets, and make smarter choices—backed by science, not hype.
